Tuesday, January 15, 2019
"Will Article 13 Kill the Internet?": attorney looks at how the EU Copyright Directive works even outside the EU
Today’s “Movie” will be a 2-hour-16-minute superchat by attorney Lior Lesig ("YouTuberLaw") , titled “Will Article 13 Kill the Internet?” It offers the hastag “#SaveYourInternet”, under the channel “Legal Dissent”.
This discussion refers to Article 13, which along with Article 11 (the Link Tax) are very controversial and disturbing proposals that are percolating in the European Union, as part of the proposed EU Copyright Directive, and are likely to go into effect in most countries by the end of 2020 at the latest.
Article 13 would hold platforms (like YouTube) responsible as the speaker for any copyright infringement from users. Various versions of the proposal limit the exposure just to “larger” commercial platforms (social media companies) and claim to recognize Fair Use but give platforms no way to protect themselves from users except to limit the content to larger users whom they know well.
Content originating outside the EU, not going through newer EU protocols, would likely be blocked in the EU, even though that could probably be circumvented by VPN’s.
Blogger, for example, probably would have to suspend EU country specific TLD’s for users who weren’r prescreened by their rules.
The whole measure seems to be an exercise in protectionism, trying to enable legacy media companies to fend off low-cost competition from newbies.
The first part of the video is a summary of the Article 13 provisions and shows the logical contradictions within the wording.